Access to heterogeneous groupings to the fullest extent possible
Effective middle schools avoid segregating EL students and those who struggle with English into permanent groupings in less rigorous tracks. Typically, such tracking minimizes student engagement in the broader school community.
In contrast, heterogeneous groupings avoid stigmatizing and segregating students who are most at risk.
The success of this method, also called mixed-ability grouping, depends on the teacher’s skill in differentiating instruction so that all students feel challenged and successful. Advocates say heterogeneous grouping prevents lower-track classes from becoming dumping grounds and ensures that all students have access to high-status content. Opponents say it is difficult for teachers to manage, hampers the brightest children from moving at an accelerated pace, and contributes to watering down the curriculum.1
Many studies support the educational benefits of heterogeneous grouping.2 As noted above, however, mixed-ability grouping requires more lesson preparation and supports for slower learners—something that professional learning community team members can develop and share.
- The following section in Taking Center Stage—Act II relates to heterogeneous groupings: Opportunities to cooperate.
- The National Middle School Association Research Summary, Heterogeneous Grouping 1996 (PDF; Outside Source), provides a list of strategies for implementing heterogeneous grouping and the research behind the theory.
Access also implies, in some cases, providing nonheterogeneous classes for students taking advanced courses such as geometry and calculus. In cases where only one or a few students need such access, partnerships may offer a viable alternative (see Chapter 12, “Partnerships,” for more examples). In addition, distance learning may be an alternative for providing specialized or advanced course work for students who have completed and excelled at grade-level work.
Previous Section
Access to grade-level, standards-based instruction
Next Section
Access to differentiated instruction
Footnotes
1 Heterogeneous Classes (Outside Source), Small Schools Project.
2 “Heterogeneous Grouping” (Outside Source), Naperville, Ill.: North Central Educational Laboratory (NCREL).